
A Witch In Notting Hill
Alexandra Paige
Avon (Harper Collins)
2025, 352p
Read via Kindle+
Blurb {from the publisher/Goodreads.com}: When rising Hollywood actress and secret witch Willow James accidentally turns her manager into a cat while trying to escape her contract, she’s sure she’s hit her magical low point. Determined to fix her mistake, she journeys to London in search of a rare spell hidden within the famed occult bookstore, Coven & Codex. The last thing she expects? The shop’s brooding, handsome owner, Oliver Hadley, who’d rather avoid magic altogether.
Together—with a ragtag group of friends (both human and feline)—Willow and Oliver must scour every corner of the city, from museums to festivals to bustling street markets, to find the missing pieces of the spell. Along the way, Willow’s unpredictable magic and Oliver’s skeptical heart will face the one thing they can’t escape… love.
Filled with enchanting adventures, sparkling romance, and a dash of mischief, A Witch in Notting Hill is a sweet and spirited tale of discovering magic where you least expect it.
Why did I allow myself to be swayed by this very cute cover?
I thought this sounded so fun. It’s a take on the movie Notting Hill but with a magical realism twist.
Willow James is a well known Hollywood actress. She also happens to be a witch, from a family where all of the women are witches. Her grandmother, mother and sister are all accomplished, talented witches but for Willow, things have never gone quite that smoothly. Her spells tend to go a bit awry and they especially go awry if she’s flustered, romantically. For that reason, she’s pretty much sworn off relationships. When her manager suggests she date or be seen to be dating a fellow actor, Willow accidentally turns her into a cat. She can’t reverse the spell so she heads to Notting Hill in London and a bookshop that has a lot of magical texts. The bookshop is run by a man named Oliver Hadley who inherited it from his great-uncle Arthur but who doesn’t at all believe in the occult and thinks that the people who frequent his bookstore are deluded.
What happens next is basically a sort of wild goose chase hunting down information and then they find out that Willow needs to do a bunch of things within a certain time frame in order to reverse the spell, so she arranges to stay in London for a few months so that she can complete them. Oliver introduces her to his two close friends, one of which is a huge fan of Willow and her movies and they are conveniently able to help with several of the steps due to their connections in the city. During this time Willow is fighting an attraction to Oliver but she has to resist because of what happens to her magic when she’s developing romantic feelings for someone – she can’t have anything going wrong when she attempts to reverse the spell. Also Oliver is a big magic skeptic and he is sort of rude about it. I wondered why Willow didn’t do some sort of basic ass spell to prove her witchiness but the book neatly sidesteps this by having some sort of unspoken rule about not being allowed to convince a skeptic with witchcraft.
I like Notting Hill but it’s not a favourite. I don’t rewatch it if I come across it or have a tradition of watching it regularly like Love Actually or Bridget Jones’ Diary. But I thought it would be a pretty cute backdrop for a novel like that and it would lend itself well to the magic realism twist. Notting Hill is a very aesthetic suburb…. does England say suburb? District? Anyway, whatever it may be and it’s full of bookshops and has a really fun vibe. So I thought I’d really love that about it. But to be honest I don’t think the book really capitalised on its London setting other than having Oliver occasionally correct Willow’s American terminology for things and having them go to pubs sometimes. They do traipse around to various locations looking for things but it just felt very surface level.
But I was so bored in this. I didn’t feel like Oliver and Willow had any chemistry at all and I didn’t feel like they really got to know each other that much either. Oliver was grumpy but also dismissive and rude to Willow but at the same time he’d keep hanging around talking about how he couldn’t be away from her or something. His friends felt like stereotypes and Willow herself even felt pretty shallowly drawn. I guess because they had to wait for a specific time of year to do some of the steps, some of the book felt a bit drawn out and even a bit repetitive as the steps were all sort of similar – go to this place, try and find this thing, realise it’s not there or they need to do something else, etc.
I think my biggest issue was that I just really didn’t warm to Oliver. His character felt really inconsistent to me, the sort of hot and cold guy that you should probably not even bother with after he insults you the first time. He says some really kind of rude things to Willow in his skepticism and okay, you’re allowed not to believe, despite the fact that you run an occult bookshop that you’ve never even bothered to really research and just assume that all of your customers are gullible. But he is really blunt about how he thinks it’s all a load of rubbish, even after he meets the cat but yet…he keeps hanging around, following after Willow, insisting on doing this and that to help. Okay mate, maybe pick a lane? They also have several disagreements that lead to them deciding that perhaps it’s best if they just go their separate ways and it lasts like, a day before one of them is back like “okay, I’m sorry and I’m going to help” and repeat.
Ultimately I just didn’t warm to this one, not the story itself and not the characters. I was pretty disappointed with it.
4/10
Book #231 of 2026































