All The Books I Can Read

1 girl….2 many books!

All The Birds Singing – Evie Wyld

on July 17, 2013

All The BirdsAll The Birds Singing
Evie Wyld
Random House AU
2013, 240p
Copy courtesy of the publisher via NetGalley

Jake White lives on an island, alone with only 50 head of sheep for company. She bought the property from older farmer Don and although tries to convince Jake to socialise among the small, tight-knit community, maybe come down to the pub occasionally, Jake refuses. She keeps to herself, doing all the jobs around the farm with only the occasional assistance from Don.

Then Jake begins losing sheep – finding just the shredded remains. The predator could be anything but what’s left of the carcasses doesn’t seem like anything Jake’s ever seen before. And she feels like something is out there in the woods beyond the paddock, watching her. With only Dog for company, Jake is surprised to find a man in her barn one night, bedding down to sleep. She intends to move him on but the night is cold and the weather bad and so she allows him to stay. After that she intends to take him in to town but events conspire against her and eventually Lloyd stays, becoming a part of life on the farm even though he knows nothing about farming.

Interspersed with the story of Jake farming her sheep alone are events from her past, living and working on various sheep stations in outback hot, dusty Australia, shaping her decision to live a solitary life in the present.

This is a really difficult book for me to review. I knew as soon as I finished it that I would really struggle. It’s a difficult story to really articulate because there are several threads, none of which really marry up and there are numerous things that are never resolved by the end of the book. In fact, very little is resolved by the end of the book.

Jake grew up in Australia and spent time working on remote sheep stations around the Port Hedland area. She’s had some terrible things happen to her in her life, she’s worked as a prostitute, she was offered a “better life” by a former client which turned into a nightmare hostage situation and then there was her time working as a shearer where she was involved in a relationship with a man named Greg, but facing difficulty from another shearer who knew secrets from her past. And in the present she lives alone on a small farm tending to 50 sheep. She’s a very tough character, particularly physically. She’s honed her physique by working out and by shearing – tough, hard labour, keeping up with men. She’s closed off, remote – she’s shut all her emotions down and she doesn’t want to connect with people or know how to do it. Don makes repeated offers that she socialise, make herself known to the other farmers in the district because she never knows when she might need a bit of help – it’s a hard life and almost impossible to do on your own.

I think the problem I had with this book was the back and forth narrative. There was nothing to indicate which time period we were in a lot of the time and I’d have to stumble my way through each section, trying to figure out where this memory was from and when it had taken place. There was no indication of time, nothing to really anchor my thoughts in helping map out some sort of timeline for Jake’s life. All the memories were just fragments and they didn’t satisfy me – I was always left wanting to know more about Jake’s life in Australia, what had happened to force her into several situations and in the end, how she had come to be on the unnamed island. The premise was so very exciting but the execution of the plotline of what is attacking the sheep just felt really lacking for me. I was always feeling like I had more questions that answers and that’s not something that I enjoy.

All of the fragments of this story were potentially great – Jake was a character I wanted to know more about, I wanted to get to know her. I could sympathise with her and I could understand the way in which she’d chosen to live. The writing will no doubt appeal to many – it’s a very stripped back and bare narrative. But for me, I’d have liked it to be more wordy – this is a pretty slim book, only 240p. I’d have loved more depth to this story. Unfortunately the simple bareness of it didn’t really work for me. However I am really in the minority for this book because it seems that almost all of the other reviews are incredibly positive.


Book #184 of 2013


All The Birds Singing is the 73rd novel read and reviewed for the Australian Women Writers Challenge 2013.


3 responses to “All The Birds Singing – Evie Wyld

  1. Wow, the plot of this novel sounds really convoluted (and more than a little melodramatic). I worry that the lack of resolution would bother me as I tend to find that sort of absence of closure irritating. Based on your review the novel simply sounds extremely unsatisfying and like something I shouldn’t waste my time on 😦 It’s a shame because as you pointed out, in the hands of a more capable writer this story undeniably had potential. The mystery surrounding the sheep intrigues me and I would love to learn more about Lloyd but I don’t think I’m willing to suffer through this one in order to get those answers (which don’t seem to be guaranteed anyway!)

  2. Oh, Bree, I loved the book. I didn’t find the narrative at all difficult to follow once I realised what she was doing with the alternating chapters. I also felt that there was some resolution at the end. We certainly know what had happened to her, and I think it closes on a positive sense regarding her finally coming to some term with her past. But it’s not all neatly tied up. And, her writing and description is gorgeous I thought.

  3. […] couldn’t stop reading and the novel came with me into my dreams the night I finished it …”  Bree  was drawn in by the characterisation (particularly of Jake)  but found the “back and forth […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: