All The Books I Can Read

1 girl….2 many books!

The Husband’s Secret – Liane Moriarty

on April 8, 2013

Husband's SecretThe Husband’s Secret
Liane Moriarty
Pan Macmillan
2013, 402p
Read from my TBR pile

Cecilia Fitzpatrick is an upstanding member of the local community. She successfully sells Tupperware, she’s president of the P&C and she’s a loving and efficient mother to her three daughters, often while her husband John-Paul is away. Whilst John-Paul is on one of his trips, Cecilia is looking in the attic for something when she finds a letter from him.

For my wife, Cecilia Fitzpatrick.
To be opened only in the event of my death.

When Cecilia questions John-Paul about it on the phone, she knows that he’s lying to her. And so she opens the envelope. But what is written on that page is the last thing she ever expected.

Tess O’Leary has fled Melbourne for Sydney to come and look after her mother who has broken her ankle. But really that’s just a convenient excuse to flee from the heartbreak that two of the most important people in her world have inflicted upon her. Enrolling her son in St Angela’s with Cecilia Fitzpatrick’s daughter Polly, Tess finds herself in the interesting position of running into an old boyfriend. Is what she wants standing right in front of her after all or does the lure of home and the familiar still hold power?

Rachel Crowley has worked in the office at St Angela’s for years. She’s still grieving her heatbreaking loss from many years ago. Every day she think she comes face to face with the reason she is so broken. In a split second she makes a decision… and lives change.

The Husband’s Secret is the most recent novel by Liane Moriarty and it’s been one I was excited about for months. I have read two of her previous novels and enjoyed them and I knew from the sound of this one that it was going to be fabulous. My excitement was further heightened by a couple of my lovely reviewer friends who had early copies and wanted to let me know just how amazing it really was!

I love a book that just cuts you off at the knees with an unexpected reveal and The Husband’s Secret did all that and more to me! We are introduced to Cecilia, Tess and Rachel and taken into their lives and through their routines and quite frankly I was wondering how on earth these three women were going to be tied together. They weren’t friends, they didn’t look like being friends but the way in which Moriarty drew them together and wove a story around them was nothing short of masterful. Cecilia is one of those “can do” people who runs committees  holds down a successful job that she’s enthusiastic about and keeps track effortlessly of all of her daughter’s extra-curricular activities. She discovers a shocking secret about her perfect husband that blows her world apart and leaves her torn between a helpless desire to do right and a selfish desire to hold things together. For me, Cecilia is the very definition of how a character can be sympathetic, yet not likable. She’s not someone I felt drawn to, I didn’t warm to her nor do I think I’d ever be friends with someone like her. But I did feel for her so very much when her whole world as she knew it came crashing down around her. I don’t know what I’d do in her situation – it’s not a black and white choice. I like to think I know what I would do but it’s one of those scenarios where you can muse on it all you like but you really would have no idea unless it actually happened and that is too horrible to even think about.

I found myself becoming really engrossed in Tess’s story – all of the three characters of Cecilia, Tess and Rachel were so well done I could imagine them all being strong enough to support a whole book revolving around them. Tess believes that she suffers from social anxiety and that after all these years, she finally has a name for the fear that cripples her when forced to make conversation with someone, or even go out for a casual night out. I have to admit, Tess’s course of action wouldn’t be mine, if I were in her shoes but I did find it fascinating because of the way she chose to handle it and her reasons why. I’m not sure how I felt about the choices Tess made later on though. I think she was very forgiving and there seemed to be a making light of what happened, and perhaps it was no big deal really, given the other events of the novel. But if I was Tess, it would’ve been a big deal to me and so therefore I did find myself thinking that particular resolution was lacking. Probably because it wasn’t what I wanted for her.

Despite that, or even perhaps because of it…this book is just so good. It’s one of the few books I’ve read recently that leaves the reader with questions. Where the characters get some resolution to certain things but there are a lot of things left unsaid and you know that for some people, the real struggle is just beginning. I found myself wondering about Cecilia and how she was going to deal with the feelings that were welling up inside of her and how she was going to stay in the life she was in. She had a reason, a purpose for doing so but I still wonder precisely how she was going to manage it. I love books that stay with me, where I find myself mulling over characters and stories in my spare time when I’m not doing anything and this book is definitely one of those. I definitely think it’s her finest book to date – her tightest and most intriguing story wise and also her best one writing wise. It’s a page turner from beginning to the very end.


Book #79 of 2013

AWW2013This is my 35th novel read and reviewed for the Australian Women Writers Challenge 2013.

6 responses to “The Husband’s Secret – Liane Moriarty

  1. Have just read this! I love Liane Moriarty too and I agree that this is her best yet.

  2. writenote1 says:

    Hey, I like the new look! Refreshing and happy 🙂

    I agree with what you said at the end about Cecilia. I don’t know how you could just “box” up that knowledge and move on. Something would have to give.

    And re Tess, do you think it’s because she did something “worse” that she’s able to forgive so lightly? Do you think her secret will eat at her?

    • Thanks! 🙂 Thought it was time for a bit of colour.

      I think it’s possible that Tess felt that way. In my mind though, what was done to her was worse because of WHO it was….I don’t think I could ever be so forgiving in her situation, in fact I know I couldn’t. I’m very stubborn and perhaps that would play against me, but if that was done to me, there’d be no going back. It’s a big secret she carries as well and you’d have to think that it would eat away, given time. These things often have a way of coming out!

      I would worry about Cecilia. That sort of bottling isn’t healthy and she’s carrying such negativity inside. You’d have to wonder how she could legitimately continue on the way she is for the next how many years? A dozen? I was definitely left thinking about her future and what would happen to her.

  3. panmacaus says:

    Gee your reviews are good – so much effort! Just wanted to quickly tell you that we’ve got reading group notes up for The Husband’s Secret on our website – sometimes I think that they’re useful in delving further into the books (as well as being RG notes!). [] Cheers – Hayley at Pan Mac

  4. […] gate nudging their children into school.”,  while Marcia of Book Muster Down Under and Bree of All the Books I Can Read were appreciative of the “complex moral choices”and the “what […]

  5. […] (Just One Night #1), by Kyra Davis Review: Tampa, by Alissa Nutting (plus giveaway) Review: The Husband’s Secret, by Liane Moriarty Review: Lick, by Kylie Scott Review: The Silver Chain, by Primula Bond […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: